theoretical vs conceptual framework

Ying Roselyn Du explores the mass media’s agenda-setting function in a context of increased globalisation to see if the theory of agenda-setting works within the global setting. She finds that “inter-nation intermedia influences” provide a new approach to move the journalistic co-orientation phenomenon to cross-national intermedia comparisons (p. 19). Yie Xie and Anne Cooper-Chen argue, in support of Daniel Riffe , that in the case of international news, “borrowing or shortcuts can save enormous amounts of time and money” but that comes with a risk of inaccuracies in national accounts (p. 92).

theoretical vs conceptual framework

I find out there are different types of satisfaction across other genres of the food service industry, and the one I’m interested in is cumulative customer satisfaction. The actionable research you’d like to conduct will help shape what you include in your framework.

Browse Journals By Subject

This framework is outlined in the Methodology section on Values driving the research. Further research in this area may be ultimately successful, but is a diversion in terms of my design practice. Clarity about the neural structure of the brain may indicate useful design issues, but often on a different level than that of thinking and learning. I suggest we can only objectively deduce the strengths and limitations of mental models by observing and analysing human behaviours, verbal utterances and written or graphic articulations – expressions.

theoretical vs conceptual framework

It however involves broad generalizations that reflect relationship between things in a phenomenon. Conceptual framework differs from theoretical framework in that it provides the direction that is missing in theoretical framework.

Similarities Between Theoretical Framework And Conceptual Framework

These types of research methods are often used for qualitative studies. Kraidy also argues that the use of hybridity as a descriptive device presents ontological and political quandaries. Ontologically, Kraidy sees hybridity not “as a clear product of global and local interactions but as a communicative practice constitutive of, and constituted by, socio-political and economic arrangements” (p. 317). A quantitative conceptual framework assists our understanding of the causal or correlational patterns of interconnections across ideas, observations, concepts and other parts of experience. Conceptual framework is defined as a network, or “plane,” of linked concepts that together provide a comprehensive understanding of a phenomenon. Each concept of a conceptual framework plays an ontological or epistemological role in the framework. Theoretical frameworks provide a particular perspective, or lens, through which to examine a topic.

theoretical vs conceptual framework

Conversely, theoretical frameworks are grounded in existing theories that have been tested consistently over time and can be supported by other researchers. Qualitative research approaches require a detailed understanding of the research process. This understanding highlights the importance of having a detailed research structure to guide the study. This paper highlights the modern portfolio theory and the corporate portfolio model as the main theoretical and conceptual frameworks, respectively, for the proposed study. Their composition captures the nature of the study and provides a clear model for answering the research questions. If using a theory-informing inductive data analysis study design, the researcher will wait until data analysis is underway to decide which theory or theories can be used to inform data interpretations. The theoretical framework of the study is, therefore, developed during the data analysis processes .

Complexity And Iteration In Design

To create a theoretical framework, the subjectivist inductive researcher must first decide which of the 3 study designs described above he or she will be using (i.e., fully inductive theory development, fully theory-informed inductive, or theory-informing inductive data analysis). This decision will guide the development of the theoretical framework, including practical decisions of research design (e.g., the design of interview or focus group questions, study participant selection, the sensitizing concepts ). Conceptual frameworks only function as structural frameworks for research. They only provide an elaborate model for a researcher on how to conduct a study and meet a desired end . A theoretical framework, on the other hand, is the foundation of research inquiry and provides much-needed guidance on how to approach a thesis. The foundation of conceptual frameworks used in research concepts which are later linked to specific variables.

However, the terms «theoretical» and «conceptual» are often confused or used interchangeably to designate all ideas used to define and shape an intellectual study. When in doubt, refer to your professor or to a source within your field of research to determine which term to use. Multiple conflicting issues can also be evaluated using a conceptual framework due to its broad nature and a clear dichotomy between theoretical principles. They also play an important role in organizing empirical research and developing a clear objective for such endeavors based on scientific inquiry . An example of a conceptual framework is a model that focuses on quality healthcare outcomes by combining nursing system characteristics, desired health outcomes, patient-centered nursing interventions, and patient trait characteristics.

Theoretical & Conceptual Framework

They focused their study on exploring how the framework informed the decision-making process of an American automotive company. Their study identified 47 financial strategies for the sampled companies and, using the corporate portfolio framework, selected ten financial options that related to the company’s key competencies (Seifi et al., 2012). The researchers eliminated 26 financial options during the first step of the corporate model to emerge with the ten options in the third step (Seifi et al., 2012). Comprehensively, the researchers explained how the corporate portfolio framework works. The same model is useful to my proposed dissertation because it outlines a framework for identifying and evaluating different financial options for improving the financial stability of Clayton County Library. Theoretical framework is based upon theories that have already been tested. These are theories that are the result of painstaking research conducted earlier by other investigators.

This complex mental model helps with other people’s reaction to my behaviour. Through it I can predict how well received a comment about someone’s performance, appearance or feelings might be, and thus choose my words carefully to achieve the effect I desire. It can go wrong and has often lead to doubt about my ability to make these judgements. It can be effective in forecasting behaviour or just as often, dissecting the reasons for upset.

  • The types of conceptual frameworks are taxonomy, visual representa- tion, and mathematical description.
  • These are represented as micro-level investigations, which correspond with individual level analysis in the Shoemaker and Reese model.
  • In that case, don’t be afraid to propose your own theory based on your findings.
  • In the objectivist deductive tradition, a theoretical framework is typically constructed before data collection and is fixed—meaning that a theoretical framework is written before the study beings and remains largely unchanged throughout the research process.
  • Our descriptions of objectivist deductive and subjectivist inductive approaches are not tied to specific paradigms.
  • A theoretical framework consists of concepts, together with their definitions, and existing theory/theories that are used for your particular study.

While the pursuit of this present study is no different, my research is unique in the sense that it provides an approach which can be used productively to discuss new debates over how the resistance of the colonised should be described. This disruption on both sides, no matter how small, constitutes a resistance of sorts. The definition of conceptual is something having to do with the mind, or with mental concepts or philosophical or imaginary ideas. An example of conceptual is when you formulate an abstract philosophy to explain the world which cannot be proven or seen. A conceptual framework helps to first identify and then clarify what you know, care about, and value as central aspects of a study and then to connect these with the various other aspects of and influences on your research (Ravitch & Riggan, 2016).

What Is Theoretical And Conceptual Framework?

And so it becomes more important to know WHY you are including specific things in your research design, instead of checking off words and terms from a list. The complexities in the description of globalisation were clearly marked out by how different scholars perceived the increasing international social relations. Identifying and learning about theories requires a different search strategy than other types of research. Even though the steps are different, you will still use many of the same skills and tools you’ve used for other library research. Try to understand what research has already been done on the subject matter and contribute. Both explain the future course of the research study justifying the reliability of the study. This is one of the most impressive way of understanding I have had ever.

Conceptual frameworks, the way I see them, are like lenses through which you can see a particular phenomenon. In this article, we highlight the transformative work that is needed for a theory to appropriately and meaningfully influence research studies that will help deepen our understanding of problems, contexts, and even the theories themselves important to HPE. But, to do this, we need to have a common understanding of the language we use and an appreciation of the different ways these terms can be applied. This language can help us better report the in-depth analytical work involved in research—a theoretical framework articulates the logic of why we are using a particular theory; a conceptual framework justifies why this problem/context/phenomenon is relevant to the field. These frameworks represent one of the most challenging aspects of research—turning a hunch, an observation, or a meandering thought into a logical, evidence-informed, theory-refining, impactful, and meaningful argument suitable for peer review and publication. While a theoretical framework provides the general set of ideas in which a study occurs, the conceptual framework refers to the specific ideas a researcher uses in the study.

  • However, the difference between them in scholarly research is important, particularly when using an experimental design.
  • This model describing critical factors impacting youth development in foster care is presented.
  • I do not believe that it is fruitful, especially for the design practitioner, to spend too long identifying mental models’ structural properties nor attempting to use mental models as a basis for formal prediction or explanation.
  • I would extend this definition so that a design may be that of an information resource, tool, activity, environment or educational organisation.
  • The conceptual framework in this present study is deduced from the theoretical framework with more focus on the specifics of the study’s arguments.

It defines the relevant variables for your study and maps out how they might relate to each other. You should construct a conceptual framework before you begin collecting data. To be rigorous, however, researchers must make an early, explicit decision as to when and how they will use theory in their research. Often, revisions to the theory will be part of the contributions made to knowledge by the research project.

In this section, the theory of newsworthiness, intermedia agenda-setting and the postcolonial theory are comprehensively reviewed as theoretical concepts. In turn, it is outlined how their application to this study offers new ways to understand them. The complimentary appreciation of these theories is to demonstrate that theoretical innovation is not to say that previous theories do not exist but to strengthen their weaknesses in their new applications especially to areas where they have not been significantly combined.

But the necessary legitimisation by the coloniser in the postcolonial space — even in the era of globalisation — is still categorised and operated with a binary framework, such as “developed and developing”; “East and West”; “poor nations and rich nations”. Identifying a theory that aligns with your dissertation or doctoral study takes time. The process of identifying an appropriate theory can seem daunting, so try breaking down the process into smaller steps. Look for the specific variables explained in the literature and examine the relationship between them. After selecting a topic for your research, carry out a literature review. Theoretical framework looks into the current research problem using the lens of past relevant theories from existing literatures. The ideas of Hargreaves concerning the interpersonal relationship between teacher and learner, Deming regarding the pursuit of quality and the cybernetics systems theory from Beer and Ashby have been influential and are discussed in this section.

Sketch the flow of your Applied Doctoral Project from start to finish and decide which variables are truly the best fit for your research. Review related literature to find how scholars have addressed your research problem. Rather than providing in-depth information, try using concise and straightforward language in your problem statement to explain your study’s purpose in an easy-to-read manner.

In a subjectivist inductive approach, the conceptual framework will likely need to evolve during a study as new ideas, insights, and knowledge are developed. As a result, a researcher will often construct a tentative conceptual framework at the beginning of the study, knowing that it will likely need to be adjusted as data transform theoretical vs conceptual framework the researcher’s understanding of the phenomenon. Our descriptions of theory, theoretical framework, and conceptual framework are simplified. To craft these descriptions, we had to wrestle with the foundational elements of research. Despite this effort, the result remains incomplete, undernuanced, and full of compromises.

Examples of conceptual frameworks include the methods of a chemistry experiment, the definitions a sociologist uses to describe a culture and the types of data an economist considers when evaluating a country’s industry. The conceptual framework thus consists of the ideas that are used to define research and evaluate data. Conceptual frameworks are often laid out at the beginning of a paper or an experiment description for a reader to understand the methods used. Different researchers have used the corporate portfolio framework to explore different topics in behavioral economics (Rocco & Plakhotnik, 2009). The first step involves identifying financial alternatives, while the second step involves evaluating the alternatives to identify, which strategic choice addresses the research objectives (Seifi, Moosavi, & Ardestani, 2012). Researchers have used this conceptual framework to identify strategic options that relate to a company’s strategic competency (Rocco & Plakhotnik, 2009). Nonetheless, the first set of researchers to use the model worked in the automotive industry and wanted to explore different strategic options for improving the financial position of the firms in the sector (Seifi et al., 2012).